predictions/suggested picks for your fave idol nxt wik

[gildalovesjc]

Share ur thoughts!!!

[Sweet Melissa]

Unless something terrible happens :eek: Jason is my pick. I think he will find the "perfect" MC or ALW song and change it to suit his style and we will all be blown away!! :D

[naniyosie]

OK...is Michael Johns back???? I see he has a song choice for Tuesday night.

[Sweet Melissa]

Where do you see that naniyosie?

[naniyosie]

I saw that under Rickey's 'song of the week' (Mariah Carey).

I love Jason, and I can't wait to hear him tonight. He is awesome!:)

[jgu22]

YES! I WIN!

I called that Carly would sing Without You. So far, my fav. of the night.

Hopefully Rickey is wrong and she lasts another week. She deserves it more that Kristy...

[jeannebug1]

I was pleasantly surprised tonight. Wasn't sure how they would do singing Mariah. Everyone did pretty good.
My favorite & #1 spot goes to David Cook
#2 Jason Castro
#3 Brook White
Tied for 4th..David A & Carly Smithson
#5 Syesha Mercado
#6 Kristy Cook

I think we will have an all girl bottom 3 with Kristy, Carly and Syesha
and hopefully either Syesha or Kristy goes home. Carly has gotten a bum rap.
I feel bad for her. She deserves another week.

[Sweet Melissa]

The guys were amazing last night! My favs:

#1 David Cook
#2 Jason Castro
#3 David A
#4 Brooke W
#5 Kristie LC
#6 Syesha M
#7 Carly

Hoping Carly will go home..................

[dc-snoopy]

Oh dear. I suppose I'm in the minority. I just don't get the drugged hippy luau that is Jason Castro. it was entertaining for a while, but it's old. And Brooke's mediocre Carole King imitation is also very old.

My ranking for the night:

1. David C
2. David A
3.Sayesha
4.Kristy Lee
5.Carly
6.Jason
7. Brooke (eliminated)

However, I think the bottom-3 will actually be Carly, Sayesha, Brooke (eliminated).

[buffylove]

Loved Jason tonight. Though Cook was good but not all that. Brooke was off and I didn't connect with David A. At times I love his voice but when I listen to his songs I keep wondering if that really is the kind of singer he is. Is that really the album he wants to record? Doesn't fit for me. Carly and Syesha were just horrible, as they've been for weeks.

My list:

#1 -- Jason
#2 -- David Cook
#3 -- Kristy
#3 -- Brooke
#4 -- David A
#6 -- Syesha
#7 -- Carly (gone)

I think the bottom 3 will be Carly, Syesha and Brooek (with a chance of Kristy instead).

Eliminated -- Carly (although I wouldn't be surprized if Syesha went instead).

[Sweet Melissa]

Guess we all called it wrong this time :confused: